Scape Scape:
Allan Rock or Manley? Get serious. Allan is the flim flam man who is crazy about gun control and is friendly in that creepy summer camp councilor who is too frisky with the boys kinda way. Manley is not exactly what I would consider outgoing either. He can speak English but he would be even more introverted than Dion.
I am not a Rock supporter at all, but he can work the backrooms and mobilize a party, and he isn't Iggy or Stephane.
I would take a bullet for Manley, he is by far Harper's equal on delving into policy minutia, despite what you say - he is very personable, fully bilingual, and I think people are naturally at ease with him and trust him. Even the PCs and Canadian Alliance admitted he was the calming effect after 9/11 and his relations with Colin Powell were exactly what Canadians wanted and needed. Manley is reasonable, measured and effective - no bluster or ego. I can think of very few Canadian politicians like him. Maybe Ed Broadbent, Art Eggleton waaay back when he was Toronto's last decent Mayor and a few Premiers over the last couple decades cross Canada.