DanSC DanSC:
I for one believe the official story, but I must admit understanding the idea that bin Laden is still alive; in custody, but alive. Dead men tell no tales, and I'm sure the U.S. wants al-Quaeda to think their secrets are still safe.
I'm not sure what the official story is anymore,
I think, just for the sake of tactics, that arresting him would have been better for the Americans. I'm sure he wouldn't be very helpful, but it'd have to be more helpful than a corpse. He's just a human being - he's not any more 'dangerous' than anyone else can be so I don't think that killing him immediately was the 'best' approach to this. Effective, certainly. Some information may be gone forever though.
Perhaps the Americans figured he had nothing special in his little head.
All things being equal yes, it would have been cool to take him alive. I would like to see the look on his face when he is aboard an American aircraft carrier and we could have shown the world that OBL is a good deal less than the holy Islamic Warrior bit.