[desertdude]

Like I said there is no excuse to kill anyone specially children and any excuse is pathetic.

[ShepherdsDog]

The first part makes no sense, and as for the second, you got all cranky over a simple question posed by another poster and made an unsubstantiated accusation. Seems you were looking for a confrontation.

[Brenda]

ShepherdsDog ShepherdsDog:

The first part makes no sense, and as for the second, you got all cranky over a simple question posed by another poster and made an unsubstantiated accusation. Seems you were looking for a confrontation.

It was not a simple question. It has been all over the board, taken from one thread to another.
That, and I think he can have his own discussions, without you butting in.

The first part makes as much sense as yours. Some people have a mental illness, others don't. Some people get cancer, others don't. You can't put everyone on the same pile just because you think they went through the same thing.

[GreenTiger]

Post Partum depression is a very serious thing some women get it some don't. The women who get this need treatment and we need to be sensitive about it. It hit the womwn who get this very hard when they least are able to deal with it.

Criminal activities are that, I don't think anybody os arguing that there are one thing or another is an excuse.

These are two separate topics or should be.

[Brenda]

It's pretty annoying to see that people shrug off a PPD or PPP as "pffff, get a grip girl". Like I've said, I had 2 PPD's, and they are not easy to deal with.

[Gunnair]

GreenTiger GreenTiger:

Post Partum depression is a very serious thing some women get it some don't. The women who get this need treatment and we need to be sensitive about it. It hit the womwn who get this very hard when they least are able to deal with it.

Criminal activities are that, I don't think anybody os arguing that there are one thing or another is an excuse.

These are two separate topics or should be.

Vince Lee beheaded a youth on a bus while undergoing a schizophrenic episode. He needs treatment and we should be sensitive about it because it hit him very hard and he could not deal with it.

Now, I actually agree with my statement. Do you?

[Brenda]

OF COURSE he should be treated. If this guy is ever going to walk the streets again, you do want him treated, and taking his meds, don't you??

[desertdude]

WTF ! walk the streets again, he should be locked up and the key thrown away for good !

[GreenTiger]

I'm not saying that laws shouldn't be enforced they need to be for the good of everybody.

When someone needs treatnment for a mental Illness they should be treated. In a civilized society we nneed to treat people where we can.

[Brenda]

desertdude desertdude:

WTF ! walk the streets again, he should be locked up and the key thrown away for good !

That would be nice, but that won't happen if he only gets jailtime for murder. If he gets treatment, he could be locked up for life in a mental facility.

Emotions and laws do not go well together...

[desertdude]

But either ways with someone like that, letting him go after he is "treated" to walk the streets shouldn't be a choice.

[Brenda]

desertdude desertdude:

But either ways with someone like that, letting him go after he is "treated" to walk the streets shouldn't be a choice.

When is the last time you have seen a one time killer being locked up for life in prison? In Canada, that is...

[desertdude]

Oh I was going to respond until I read the last sentence. In Canada I don't know and maybe that needs to change and the penal system needs to MTFU

[stratos]

Brenda Brenda:

It's pretty annoying to see that people shrug off a PPD or PPP as "pffff, get a grip girl". Like I've said, I had 2 PPD's, and they are not easy to deal with.

Thats the point though Brenda you did not go and kill someone. At least that we know of

[stratos]

Brenda Brenda:

desertdude desertdude:

But either ways with someone like that, letting him go after he is "treated" to walk the streets shouldn't be a choice.

When is the last time you have seen a one time killer being locked up for life in prison? In Canada, that is...

Killed multiable kids in one time. Does that count as a one time thing or as a double homicide ect.. like they do sometimes here in the states?