Eight national retailers — Co-op Atlantic, Canada Safeway, Costco, Federated Co-operatives Limited, Loblaw’s, Metro, Sobeys, and Walmart — announced their intentions Monday to stop buying pork produced in intensive confinement cages, or “gestation stalls”
Not that I don't think it's a good move. The way animals are treated in commercial faarming is beyond horrifying in many cases, but if an entire industry has to try making major fundemental changes like this I could see the cost being too great for consumers to go along.
We all know how quick people are to condem all sorts of social ills, even as they're driving the 3 blocks to wal-mart or wherever to save 5c on a pack of KD.
Isn't all meat produced in an inhumane manner? It's a fact we all have to deal with. So really the only options are to accept that our meat is produced in a horribly inhumane and unhealthy manner, or find a local butcher that doesn't carry factory farmed meat.
I suppose it depends on your definition of "inhumane". There are those who think that just miling a cow is inhumane, and others who see nothing wrong with chicken pr pigs spending their entire lives in cages that are too small for them to move out of their own waste. I think most of us however are more comfortable with something in the middle.
I buy direct from local farmers but I don't delude myself by believing that the animals I eat enjoyed a King's life compared to those who got shipped out of a factory farm.
"Unsound" said I wonder how much this will affect prices?
Not that I don't think it's a good move. The way animals are treated in commercial faarming is beyond horrifying in many cases, but if an entire industry has to try making major fundemental changes like this I could see the cost being too great for consumers to go along.
We all know how quick people are to condem all sorts of social ills, even as they're driving the 3 blocks to wal-mart or wherever to save 5c on a pack of KD.
Good to some extent, meat isn't supposed to be a regular part of meals, it's supposed to be a smaller food while we eat veggie heavy meals.
I dont think it will affect prices much. First, if you.notice, theyre phasing it.in over 10 years...not exactly radical pace.
Second, most of the price difference (indeed if there is currently any at all) is likely just attributable to volume. If you produce 10 units of a product under method x and 1 unit under method y, the marginal cost under method x will be cheaper. If you then switch it up to produce 10y and only 1 x, then y could be cheaper. This is partly why its cheaper to sell you food with junk added to it than to sell you the same food without junk added to it. Coca cola is just water with stuff added to it, but its cheaper than just plain water, for example.
Good to some extent, meat isn't supposed to be a regular part of meals, it's supposed to be a smaller food while we eat veggie heavy meals.
says who?? Quality protein(fish, eggs, poultry and smaller amounts of beef or pork) should be a regular component of every meal, along with lots of low carb vegetables. This is the healthiest way to eat.
"jeff744" said Good to some extent, meat isn't supposed to be a regular part of meals, it's supposed to be a smaller food while we eat veggie heavy meals.
Supposed?
The implication of intent for human biology make me smirk.
Good to some extent, meat isn't supposed to be a regular part of meals, it's supposed to be a smaller food while we eat veggie heavy meals.
says who?? Quality protein(fish, eggs, poultry and smaller amounts of beef or pork) should be a regular component of every meal, along with lots of low carb vegetables. This is the healthiest way to eat.
Yes but we aren't used to huge portions of meat, we are supposed to eat it but we still always ate more fruits, grains, and veggies than meat.
not grains we weren't....that's a recent addition to our diet in evolutionary terms(8000 - 10000 years ago). Roots, seasonal fruits, nuts and berries were staples and meat when we could kill or scavenge it. Humanity has always been a big consumer of protein derived from tidal waters, lakes and rivers. If you look at most primitive cultures, protein plays a central role in their diet because it is nutrient dense, loaded with fat soluble vitamins. The plant foods supplemented the protein portion
"ShepherdsDog" said not grains we weren't....that's a recent addition to our diet in evolutionary terms(8000 - 10000 years ago).
Further to your point, domesticated food animals, such as cows, chickens, pigs, etc. are even more recent additions to our diet and today bear little resemblance to their wild ancestors that ancient people hunted. I think we would all agree that nothing in the wild resembles a Black Angus or a Holstein cow and this has changed their nutritional composition. In some cases, our food species have changed dramatically just in the past 50 years, thanks to industrial farming and food manufacturing, which has even further changed their nutritional profile. Our food animals are bred for productive cost efficiency, not nutritional value, so it follows that selective breeding for the former would result in loss of the latter.
It has also been suggested that humans, who are relatively sedentary relative to our ancestors don't have high protein demands unless they are highly active individuals and over-consume protein anyway.
I think we would all agree that nothing in the wild resembles a Black Angus or a Holstein cow and this has changed their nutritional composition.
I will agree that the physical form is different but I dd not just agree that the nutritional composition is different without question or comment.
In some cases, our food species have changed dramatically just in the past 50 years, thanks to industrial farming and food manufacturing, which has even further changed their nutritional profile.
Such as? What has changed in terms of nurtrition?
Our food animals are bred for productive cost efficiency, not nutritional value, so it follows that selective breeding for the former would result in loss of the latter.
It's not a logical requirement that one aspect comes at the expense of the other, you will need to offer up evidence rather than the pure reason you have been trying to pass as facts.
It has also been suggested that humans, who are relatively sedentary relative to our ancestors don't have high protein demands unless they are highly active individuals and over-consume protein anyway.
Suggested by who?
I believe the point isn't that we need lots of protein, but that meat is a high nutrition food source.
Not that I don't think it's a good move. The way animals are treated in commercial faarming is beyond horrifying in many cases, but if an entire industry has to try making major fundemental changes like this I could see the cost being too great for consumers to go along.
We all know how quick people are to condem all sorts of social ills, even as they're driving the 3 blocks to wal-mart or wherever to save 5c on a pack of KD.
I wonder how much this will affect prices?
Not that I don't think it's a good move. The way animals are treated in commercial faarming is beyond horrifying in many cases, but if an entire industry has to try making major fundemental changes like this I could see the cost being too great for consumers to go along.
We all know how quick people are to condem all sorts of social ills, even as they're driving the 3 blocks to wal-mart or wherever to save 5c on a pack of KD.
Good to some extent, meat isn't supposed to be a regular part of meals, it's supposed to be a smaller food while we eat veggie heavy meals.
Second, most of the price difference (indeed if there is currently any at all) is likely just attributable to volume. If you produce 10 units of a product under method x and 1 unit under method y, the marginal cost under method x will be cheaper. If you then switch it up to produce 10y and only 1 x, then y could be cheaper. This is partly why its cheaper to sell you food with junk added to it than to sell you the same food without junk added to it. Coca cola is just water with stuff added to it, but its cheaper than just plain water, for example.
Good to some extent, meat isn't supposed to be a regular part of meals, it's supposed to be a smaller food while we eat veggie heavy meals.
says who?? Quality protein(fish, eggs, poultry and smaller amounts of beef or pork) should be a regular component of every meal, along with lots of low carb vegetables. This is the healthiest way to eat.
Good to some extent, meat isn't supposed to be a regular part of meals, it's supposed to be a smaller food while we eat veggie heavy meals.
Supposed?
The implication of intent for human biology make me smirk.
Good to some extent, meat isn't supposed to be a regular part of meals, it's supposed to be a smaller food while we eat veggie heavy meals.
says who?? Quality protein(fish, eggs, poultry and smaller amounts of beef or pork) should be a regular component of every meal, along with lots of low carb vegetables. This is the healthiest way to eat.
Yes but we aren't used to huge portions of meat, we are supposed to eat it but we still always ate more fruits, grains, and veggies than meat.
not grains we weren't....that's a recent addition to our diet in evolutionary terms(8000 - 10000 years ago).
Further to your point, domesticated food animals, such as cows, chickens, pigs, etc. are even more recent additions to our diet and today bear little resemblance to their wild ancestors that ancient people hunted. I think we would all agree that nothing in the wild resembles a Black Angus or a Holstein cow and this has changed their nutritional composition. In some cases, our food species have changed dramatically just in the past 50 years, thanks to industrial farming and food manufacturing, which has even further changed their nutritional profile. Our food animals are bred for productive cost efficiency, not nutritional value, so it follows that selective breeding for the former would result in loss of the latter.
It has also been suggested that humans, who are relatively sedentary relative to our ancestors don't have high protein demands unless they are highly active individuals and over-consume protein anyway.
How is pork inhumane?
I think we would all agree that nothing in the wild resembles a Black Angus or a Holstein cow and this has changed their nutritional composition.
Suggested by who?
I believe the point isn't that we need lots of protein, but that meat is a high nutrition food source.