A Toronto man charged with plotting to derail a VIA Rail train fled to Canada from Germany after his family was “terrorized” by anti-immigrant groups there, according to federal refugee documents
*If* the story is true, I'm not surprised one of the family went over to the Dark Side. And no, I'm not excusing terrorism, just pointing out root causes.
"martin14" said The 'root' cause was letting them in with fake passports in the first place, and then not booting them out, Palis or no.
Poster family for what is wrong with Immigration.
I was going to say. So they have fake French passports to get refugee status FROM GERMANY? I mean, 1993 Germany wasn't a utopia, considering the troubles after reunification, but they weren't exactly Somalia, were they?
So, I'm guessing German authorities have record of their house being firebombed back in the early 90s?
"martin14" said The 'root' cause was letting them in with fake passports in the first place, and then not booting them out, Palis or no.
Poster family for what is wrong with Immigration.
Problem with that is you need a country on the end that is willing (or obligated) to receive the deportee. In the case of stateless persons, there is no such country. IMO, Israel should be forced to receive Palestinian deportees, but that will never happen as long as the Pro-Israel lobby still runs the show in the US.
Frankly, if the story is true, then I'm surprised the whole family isn't radicalized and the fact that they don't seem to be - in fact the father apparently sought help for this son's radicalism - I think just shows that "most" Muslims aren't terrorist sympathizers. But I bet they're all under surveillance now.
Problem with that is you need a country on the end that is willing (or obligated) to receive the deportee. In the case of stateless persons, there is no such country. IMO, Israel should be forced to receive Palestinian deportees, but that will never happen as long as the Pro-Israel lobby still runs the show in the US.
It'll never happen, period. Israel has the right to choose who they accept, or refuse as immigrants, refugees, or whoever else as they see fit. Trying to blame the pro-Israel lobby in the US for that is laughable.
It'll never happen, period. Israel has the right to choose who they accept, or refuse as immigrants, refugees, or whoever else as they see fit. Trying to blame the pro-Israel lobby in the US for that is laughable.
No they don't have the absolute right to choose. For example, if Canada wanted to deport Isreali citizens back home, Israel wouldn't have the right to refuse. Seeing as this family came from (what is now) Israel and had their lands and possessions confiscated by that state, it makes sense that's where they should go back to.
However, Israel refuses to recognize Palestinian Right of Return and never will as long as the US avoids pressuring them to do so.
Just makes it even more despicable that he would try to do this to a country that did give him refuge. I sure hope we can get rid of this scum after he's released.
No they don't have the absolute right to choose, if these people were Israeli citizens, they wouldn't have the right to refuse deportation to Israel. Seeing as this family came from (what is now) Israel and had their lands and possessions confiscated by that state, it makes sense that's where they should go back to.
However, Israel refuses to recognize Palestinian Right of Return and never will as long as the US avoids pressuring them to do so.
Except, they are not Israeli citizens, are they? The mother was born in Saudi Arabia, and did not receive citizenship rights in that country. The father was born in Jaffa, back when both sides were forcefully evicting the other out of their homes. So really, only the father can maybe claim Israeli citizenship (and, of course, plenty of Arabs did not relocate, and DID become Israeli citizens, but his family either chose, or were forced to leave. Which one? Only his long dead parents know).
However, the Israeli War of Independence did not just create Arab refugees, but Jewish ones as well (which seemingly are non-factors when the refugee crisis caused by the various Israeli-Arab wars are discussed). Those displaced peoples, both Arabs and Jews, probably aren't happy they were forcefully evicted from their homes, and had their lands and possessions confiscated. It's sadly a reality of war, though, and neither side will ever make amends to the refugees they created. (and good odds those Jews lost a fuckton more land and possessions, especially when the overwhelming majority of Arabs living in the British Mandate of Palestine were tenant farmers). Of course, one factor might be that Jewish refugees were able to gain citizenship and protections in their adoptive countries. The Palestinians were nowhere near lucky.
But, hey, even with the Arabs doing the exact same thing to Jews due to the conflict, Israel should be forced to make millions of Arabs citizens because they are the children, grandchildren, and great grandchildren of those who were forced out, or willingly left during a conflict 70 years ago because...something. Let's ignore the logistical and security considerations of such an event (and they're massive), why should the Palestinians get special consideration of a "right of return" when no such consideration has ever occurred to refugees of past conflicts (say, the Partition of Pakistan and India)? Even if the United States put pressure on Israel, Israel will never, ever accept the right of return. It's demographic, and quite possibly literal suicide for Israel. It will never happen. The Palestinians are deluding themselves if they think otherwise.
So, the father was born in what will become Israel, but leaves the country when he's 1 year old, the mother was born in Saudi Arabia, and Raed, the accused terrorist, was born in the U.A.E., and his brothers were born in Jordan. Any of those countries grant citizenship status to this family, or members of said family that seemingly was hard working and prosperous? No, of course not. They spent their lives in Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Jordan, and the U.A.E., with some extended stays in Jordan and the U.A.E. Seemingly, the Jasers spend over two decades in the U.A.E., but were kicked out of the country once the Palestinian leadership support Saddam in the Gulf War. Raed would have been 12 once this happened, so certainly losing his home, property, and his friends because Arafat was a fucking moron would have been traumatizing. Certainly this would be a root cause of terrorism.
But hey, he was traumatized by the U.A.E. telling his family to get the fuck out of the U.A.E. (even those Raed was born in the U.A.E.) because of Arafat supporting Saddam's invasion of Kuwait. I can see him being resentful and angry at the U.A.E. and the Palestinian leadership over that. Call it a root cause, even. Hell, his family history post-Israeli War of Independence just highlights how the various Arab countries failed to integrate the refugees into their society, but left them perpetually nationless, and hell, the Jasers had the opportunity to enjoy the hospitality of some of the better Arab states when it came to refugees! Raed's "root cause" of terrorism stems with his family being kicked out of the U.A.E., and then the German firebombing attack 3 years later, allowed the Jaser family to gain citizenship in Canada.
What does Raed do? Focus on the Arabs who shat on his family for decades? Nah. The Germans who firebombed his home at 15? Nope! Hell, what about the Israelis? Was he going to blow up the Israeli embassy? Nope. Let's blow up a train of Canadians, the people from the only country that didn't find a way to take a flaming dump on the Jasers. Really, the Jaser family's story is tragic, but you are right that it shows that the father was an honorable man, trying to do right by his family while being in this difficult situation. The father went through being a refugee from the Israeli War of Independence, and spent a lot of time relocating and trying to find a place to accept him. Once he did, he spent decades making a life for himself, only to have that taken away. The father has so many potential "root causes" for terrorism, and yet, he's a good man. His son? I'm sorry to say, the apple can roll down a huge fucking hill after falling from the tree.
No, it's not. Besides, they are not from the Occupied Territories that are commonly referred to now as "Palestine". they are from land that is currently within the borders of Israel proper.
So really, only the father can maybe claim Israeli citizenship (and, of course, plenty of Arabs did not relocate, and DID become Israeli citizens, but his family either chose, or were forced to leave. Which one?
It doesn't really matter whether they 'could have' hunkered down and stuck out through the turmoil or whether they were forcefully put on a bus to the border. But for the record, about 75% of displaced Palestinians are believed to be the result of direct Israeli action. In most other countries in the world, they would have the right to return under international law. Yes, some countries are scofflaws and refuse to recognize that and Israel is among them. Even people expelled from various Stalinist-type regimes have maintained and even exercised the rights to return.
By contrast, there are no stateless Jews floating around the world as Israel has a LAW OF RETURN for Jews, that states any Jew anywhere in the world has the right to automatic Israeli citizenship, even if their ancestors didn't come from that part of the world, or left thousands of years ago. Israel even subsidies their immigration. I'm sure any Jew who was displaced in in Israel long ago received that land back or was resettled elsewhere in the state. I'm also not sure your historical account is accurate, it sounds like you're saying the majority of land in British Palestine was Jewish-owned and large amounts of it were forcibly seized by Arabs, who still occupy those lands? That doesn't sound correct.
But, hey, even with the Arabs doing the exact same thing to Jews due to the conflict, Israel should be forced to make millions of Arabs citizens because they are the children, grandchildren, and great grandchildren of those who were forced out, or willingly left during a conflict 70 years ago because...something.
That's funny because the whole reason Israel was created as a "Jewish State" in 1948 and the reason that any Jew anywhere in the world can have instant Israeli citizenship is because the Jewish people lived there thousands of years ago. Many Jews aren't even the descendents of Hebrew peoples are instead descended from Eastern Europeans who converted to Judaism in Roman and Byzantine eras. So Jews have the right to return to a land they're not even from, or their ancestors haven't been in 2000 years, but Palestinians who fled their homes in 1960's can't go back.
They spent their lives in Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Jordan, and the U.A.E...how the various Arab countries failed to integrate the refugees into their society, but left them perpetually nationless...What does Raed do? Focus on the Arabs who shat on his family for decades?
Three things here: 1) You are trying to lay blame at UAE,Egypt, etc. for failing to meet some obligation to integrate displaced refugees rather than place any blame on the country that displaced them in first place. It's not some other country's job to just "deal with" whatever mess another country creates.
2) On a similar note: Country A forcibly drives a people from their homeland who flee into Country B. Country B refuses to absorb them, saying they belong in Country A. Your conclusion: shame on Country B. Are you saying that Canada should absorb them since the onus is on the country that receives the refuguee and not on the country that caused them to be refugees? I'm sure if these were, say Iraqi refugees you would want them to go back to Iraq (or at least have the right to do so), and not claim Canada has an obligation to naturalize them.
3) You seem puzzled why he would direct his anger at the West instead of UAE, Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabia. But what do these countries all have in common? All are "US allies" that are ruled by regimes that are despised by Islamists as US puppets. You might see these Arab states as distinct or in fact opposite to Western countries, but form the perspective of many Arabs, they are the same side. It's the West that keeps those regimes in power.
The father has so many potential "root causes" for terrorism, and yet, he's a good man. His son? I'm sorry to say, the apple can roll down a huge fucking hill after falling from the tree.
Absolutely. But we have to accept that these event causes the likelihood of terrorist sympathy to increase, not that it guarantees terrorism. Just like we know cigarette smoking causes cancer, even though many people smoke their whole lives and never get cancer.
Poster family for what is wrong with Immigration.
The 'root' cause was letting them in with fake passports in the first place, and then not booting them out, Palis or no.
Poster family for what is wrong with Immigration.
I was going to say. So they have fake French passports to get refugee status FROM GERMANY? I mean, 1993 Germany wasn't a utopia, considering the troubles after reunification, but they weren't exactly Somalia, were they?
So, I'm guessing German authorities have record of their house being firebombed back in the early 90s?
The 'root' cause was letting them in with fake passports in the first place, and then not booting them out, Palis or no.
Poster family for what is wrong with Immigration.
Problem with that is you need a country on the end that is willing (or obligated) to receive the deportee. In the case of stateless persons, there is no such country. IMO, Israel should be forced to receive Palestinian deportees, but that will never happen as long as the Pro-Israel lobby still runs the show in the US.
Frankly, if the story is true, then I'm surprised the whole family isn't radicalized and the fact that they don't seem to be - in fact the father apparently sought help for this son's radicalism - I think just shows that "most" Muslims aren't terrorist sympathizers. But I bet they're all under surveillance now.
Problem with that is you need a country on the end that is willing (or obligated) to receive the deportee. In the case of stateless persons, there is no such country. IMO, Israel should be forced to receive Palestinian deportees, but that will never happen as long as the Pro-Israel lobby still runs the show in the US.
It'll never happen, period. Israel has the right to choose who they accept, or refuse as immigrants, refugees, or whoever else as they see fit. Trying to blame the pro-Israel lobby in the US for that is laughable.
It'll never happen, period. Israel has the right to choose who they accept, or refuse as immigrants, refugees, or whoever else as they see fit. Trying to blame the pro-Israel lobby in the US for that is laughable.
No they don't have the absolute right to choose. For example, if Canada wanted to deport Isreali citizens back home, Israel wouldn't have the right to refuse. Seeing as this family came from (what is now) Israel and had their lands and possessions confiscated by that state, it makes sense that's where they should go back to.
However, Israel refuses to recognize Palestinian Right of Return and never will as long as the US avoids pressuring them to do so.
No they don't have the absolute right to choose, if these people were Israeli citizens, they wouldn't have the right to refuse deportation to Israel. Seeing as this family came from (what is now) Israel and had their lands and possessions confiscated by that state, it makes sense that's where they should go back to.
However, Israel refuses to recognize Palestinian Right of Return and never will as long as the US avoids pressuring them to do so.
Except, they are not Israeli citizens, are they? The mother was born in Saudi Arabia, and did not receive citizenship rights in that country. The father was born in Jaffa, back when both sides were forcefully evicting the other out of their homes. So really, only the father can maybe claim Israeli citizenship (and, of course, plenty of Arabs did not relocate, and DID become Israeli citizens, but his family either chose, or were forced to leave. Which one? Only his long dead parents know).
However, the Israeli War of Independence did not just create Arab refugees, but Jewish ones as well (which seemingly are non-factors when the refugee crisis caused by the various Israeli-Arab wars are discussed). Those displaced peoples, both Arabs and Jews, probably aren't happy they were forcefully evicted from their homes, and had their lands and possessions confiscated. It's sadly a reality of war, though, and neither side will ever make amends to the refugees they created. (and good odds those Jews lost a fuckton more land and possessions, especially when the overwhelming majority of Arabs living in the British Mandate of Palestine were tenant farmers). Of course, one factor might be that Jewish refugees were able to gain citizenship and protections in their adoptive countries. The Palestinians were nowhere near lucky.
But, hey, even with the Arabs doing the exact same thing to Jews due to the conflict, Israel should be forced to make millions of Arabs citizens because they are the children, grandchildren, and great grandchildren of those who were forced out, or willingly left during a conflict 70 years ago because...something. Let's ignore the logistical and security considerations of such an event (and they're massive), why should the Palestinians get special consideration of a "right of return" when no such consideration has ever occurred to refugees of past conflicts (say, the Partition of Pakistan and India)? Even if the United States put pressure on Israel, Israel will never, ever accept the right of return. It's demographic, and quite possibly literal suicide for Israel. It will never happen. The Palestinians are deluding themselves if they think otherwise.
So, the father was born in what will become Israel, but leaves the country when he's 1 year old, the mother was born in Saudi Arabia, and Raed, the accused terrorist, was born in the U.A.E., and his brothers were born in Jordan. Any of those countries grant citizenship status to this family, or members of said family that seemingly was hard working and prosperous? No, of course not. They spent their lives in Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Jordan, and the U.A.E., with some extended stays in Jordan and the U.A.E. Seemingly, the Jasers spend over two decades in the U.A.E., but were kicked out of the country once the Palestinian leadership support Saddam in the Gulf War. Raed would have been 12 once this happened, so certainly losing his home, property, and his friends because Arafat was a fucking moron would have been traumatizing. Certainly this would be a root cause of terrorism.
But hey, he was traumatized by the U.A.E. telling his family to get the fuck out of the U.A.E. (even those Raed was born in the U.A.E.) because of Arafat supporting Saddam's invasion of Kuwait. I can see him being resentful and angry at the U.A.E. and the Palestinian leadership over that. Call it a root cause, even. Hell, his family history post-Israeli War of Independence just highlights how the various Arab countries failed to integrate the refugees into their society, but left them perpetually nationless, and hell, the Jasers had the opportunity to enjoy the hospitality of some of the better Arab states when it came to refugees! Raed's "root cause" of terrorism stems with his family being kicked out of the U.A.E., and then the German firebombing attack 3 years later, allowed the Jaser family to gain citizenship in Canada.
What does Raed do? Focus on the Arabs who shat on his family for decades? Nah. The Germans who firebombed his home at 15? Nope! Hell, what about the Israelis? Was he going to blow up the Israeli embassy? Nope. Let's blow up a train of Canadians, the people from the only country that didn't find a way to take a flaming dump on the Jasers. Really, the Jaser family's story is tragic, but you are right that it shows that the father was an honorable man, trying to do right by his family while being in this difficult situation. The father went through being a refugee from the Israeli War of Independence, and spent a lot of time relocating and trying to find a place to accept him. Once he did, he spent decades making a life for himself, only to have that taken away. The father has so many potential "root causes" for terrorism, and yet, he's a good man. His son? I'm sorry to say, the apple can roll down a huge fucking hill after falling from the tree.
He was feeling excluded
He needs to be excluded.
No, it's not. Besides, they are not from the Occupied Territories that are commonly referred to now as "Palestine". they are from land that is currently within the borders of Israel proper.
So really, only the father can maybe claim Israeli citizenship (and, of course, plenty of Arabs did not relocate, and DID become Israeli citizens, but his family either chose, or were forced to leave. Which one?
It doesn't really matter whether they 'could have' hunkered down and stuck out through the turmoil or whether they were forcefully put on a bus to the border. But for the record, about 75% of displaced Palestinians are believed to be the result of direct Israeli action. In most other countries in the world, they would have the right to return under international law. Yes, some countries are scofflaws and refuse to recognize that and Israel is among them. Even people expelled from various Stalinist-type regimes have maintained and even exercised the rights to return.
By contrast, there are no stateless Jews floating around the world as Israel has a LAW OF RETURN for Jews, that states any Jew anywhere in the world has the right to automatic Israeli citizenship, even if their ancestors didn't come from that part of the world, or left thousands of years ago. Israel even subsidies their immigration. I'm sure any Jew who was displaced in in Israel long ago received that land back or was resettled elsewhere in the state. I'm also not sure your historical account is accurate, it sounds like you're saying the majority of land in British Palestine was Jewish-owned and large amounts of it were forcibly seized by Arabs, who still occupy those lands? That doesn't sound correct.
But, hey, even with the Arabs doing the exact same thing to Jews due to the conflict, Israel should be forced to make millions of Arabs citizens because they are the children, grandchildren, and great grandchildren of those who were forced out, or willingly left during a conflict 70 years ago because...something.
That's funny because the whole reason Israel was created as a "Jewish State" in 1948 and the reason that any Jew anywhere in the world can have instant Israeli citizenship is because the Jewish people lived there thousands of years ago. Many Jews aren't even the descendents of Hebrew peoples are instead descended from Eastern Europeans who converted to Judaism in Roman and Byzantine eras. So Jews have the right to return to a land they're not even from, or their ancestors haven't been in 2000 years, but Palestinians who fled their homes in 1960's can't go back.
Three things here:
1) You are trying to lay blame at UAE,Egypt, etc. for failing to meet some obligation to integrate displaced refugees rather than place any blame on the country that displaced them in first place. It's not some other country's job to just "deal with" whatever mess another country creates.
2) On a similar note: Country A forcibly drives a people from their homeland who flee into Country B. Country B refuses to absorb them, saying they belong in Country A. Your conclusion: shame on Country B. Are you saying that Canada should absorb them since the onus is on the country that receives the refuguee and not on the country that caused them to be refugees? I'm sure if these were, say Iraqi refugees you would want them to go back to Iraq (or at least have the right to do so), and not claim Canada has an obligation to naturalize them.
3) You seem puzzled why he would direct his anger at the West instead of UAE, Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabia. But what do these countries all have in common? All are "US allies" that are ruled by regimes that are despised by Islamists as US puppets. You might see these Arab states as distinct or in fact opposite to Western countries, but form the perspective of many Arabs, they are the same side. It's the West that keeps those regimes in power.